The Amazing Mr Toothpaste appears in the following leaderboards:

• bottle of fruity "wine"
• candy carrot
• delicious star salad
• Doublepunchplanter
• eldritch mushroom
• enticing mayolus
• Green Muslin
• idiot brain
• initiative shawarma
• Jeppson's Malort
• loaf of alien bread
• Lollipop Drop
• mulberry
• nothingtini
• pie man was not meant to eat
• piscatini
• plate of Pork 'n' Pork 'n' Pork 'n' Beans
• plate of Shrub's Premium Baked Beans
• plate of Val-U Brand Every Bean Salad
• Sangria de Menthe
• single swig of vodka
• snakebite
• toast with spooky jelly
• uninteresting mayolus
• vodka stinger
• water log