Nachtmahr appears in the following leaderboards:

• bottle of peppermint schnapps
• boxing-glove-in-a-box
• can of franks 'n' beans
• chocolate-covered diamond-studded roses
• circular CRIMBCOOKIE
• deck of lewd playing cards
• Ellsbury's skull
• floaty inverse geode
• marshmallow
• penguin paste
• square CRIMBCOOKIE
• stuffed spooky mushroom
• tin rations
• triangular CRIMBCOOKIE
• white-label gin